Abongile Tom: A Controversial Figure in South African Football and the Future of VAR
In the world of South African football, few names evoke as much controversy as that of referee Abongile Tom.
His officiating has come under intense scrutiny, with many fans and analysts questioning his decisions and overall competence.
Recently, Gayton McKenzie, a prominent figure in the sport, voiced his concerns about Tom’s performance, labeling him a “disgrace” to South African football.
The criticism stems from a series of questionable calls made by Tom during crucial matches, particularly one involving Orlando Pirates.
During a recent encounter, McKenzie expressed his disbelief at a pivotal offside decision that he claimed was a staggering three meters offside.
“This is very painful to lose over such a blatant error,” he lamented.
“The integrity of our football is at stake if this continues.”
Orlando Pirates, a team with a rich history and passionate fanbase, found themselves at the center of this controversy.
While they played well and created numerous opportunities, the officiating decisions left fans and players alike feeling robbed.
McKenzie stated, “Somebody must go to jail for that.
You can’t do such things in football.”
The history of Abongile Tom’s officiating is marred with incidents that have raised eyebrows.
In 2019, he made dubious calls during a match between Orlando Pirates and Highlands Park, allowing a goal scored from an offside position.
This decision infuriated coach Owen de Gama, who felt that the integrity of the game had been compromised.
Similarly, in 2023, Tom was suspended for four weeks due to poor officiating in a match between Kaizer Chiefs and Mamelodi Sundowns, where another offside goal led to a significant defeat for Chiefs.
The backlash against Tom’s decisions has been relentless.
Former match official Victor Clani pointed out that SuperSport United should have been awarded a penalty during a match against Orlando Pirates due to a handball by an Orlando player.
Furthermore, he highlighted that Pirates’ first goal should have been disallowed for offside, illustrating a pattern of questionable officiating that has left fans frustrated.
As discussions surrounding Tom’s future in officiating continue, the broader implications for South African football cannot be ignored.
McKenzie and others have called for a serious reevaluation of the standards and training for referees in the league.
“The credibility of our football is being destroyed,” he warned.
“If referees are not held accountable for their mistakes, we will continue to see these blunders.”
One potential solution that has been proposed is the implementation of Video Assistant Referee (VAR) technology.
McKenzie acknowledged that while VAR could help reduce errors, he expressed skepticism about its effectiveness.
“I don’t like VAR,” he said.
“It takes away the fun and authenticity of football.
It’s not even 100% accurate, and if we still have referees like Tom, poor officiating will continue regardless.”
The debate over VAR’s role in South African football is ongoing.
While some supporters believe it could enhance the quality of officiating, others worry about the potential for further complications and delays in the game.
The South African Football Association (SAFA) has indicated that they are taking steps to implement VAR, with plans to invest significantly in training match officials and replay operators.
Reports suggest that other countries, such as Morocco and Egypt, spend around 23 million rand per season on VAR, raising questions about whether South Africa is prepared to make a similar commitment.
Abdul Ibrahim, the head of South African referees, stated that training 20 match officials and replay operators would cost approximately 1.5 million rand.
This investment is seen as crucial to improving the quality of officiating and restoring faith in the system.
As the debate continues, fans are left wondering what the future holds for South African football.
Will the implementation of VAR lead to better officiating, or will it simply add another layer of complexity to the game?
The answer remains uncertain, but one thing is clear: the need for improvement in officiating standards is urgent.
Abongile Tom’s controversial reputation has raised significant concerns about the overall quality of refereeing in South Africa.
As the league moves forward, it will be essential for all stakeholders to work together to enhance the officiating process and restore credibility to the sport.
In conclusion, the ongoing discussions surrounding Abongile Tom and the potential implementation of VAR highlight the critical need for change in South African football.
While the passion for the game remains strong, the integrity of the sport must be preserved.
Only through collaboration and commitment to excellence can South African football continue to thrive and maintain its rich legacy.
As fans, players, and officials reflect on the current state of the game, the hope is that necessary reforms will be made to ensure a bright future for South African football.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
