The Trial of Kelly Smith and Her Accomplices: A Family’s Tragic Story Unfolds
In a case that has captured the attention of South Africa, Kelly Smith, her boyfriend Jacquwin Apollus, and their friend Stephano Fonrain are on trial for the kidnapping and trafficking of 6-year-old Joshyn Smith.
The trial has revealed shocking details about the events leading up to Joshyn’s disappearance and the circumstances surrounding the accusations against the trio.
While Kelly Smith and her accomplices pleaded not guilty to the charges, the court has been presented with a complex story that involves drug use, inconsistent testimonies, and disturbing confessions.
The Day Joshyn Disappeared: A Shocking Account
On the day of Joshyn’s disappearance, Kelly Smith and Apollus provided an account of the events.
According to their testimony, Joshyn and her older brother did not go to school that day because their uniforms were dirty.
Instead, they stayed home with Apollus while Kelly went to work as a domestic worker.
Kelly told the court that she borrowed 5050 South African Rand from her employer to buy drugs, which she smoked with Apollus when she returned home around lunchtime.
At that time, Joshyn and her brother were reportedly in the bath, washing themselves.
Kelly explained that after returning to work, she came back at around 5:00 p.m., again borrowing money to buy more drugs.
She smoked with Apollus and Fonrain, but upon returning home, she found that Joshyn was not there.
Apollus allegedly told her that Joshyn was with her friends, but when Kelly’s son returned home, he said he had not seen his sister.
She then sent him to the park to search for her, but when he returned with no news, Kelly began to panic.
She immediately informed her neighbor, Namla, that she could not find Joshyn.
The search for Joshyn began, with the community coming together to help.
Despite their efforts, Joshyn remained missing, and Kelly became hysterical, claiming that she had nothing to do with her daughter’s disappearance.
She denied all allegations and pleaded not guilty to the charges of kidnapping and trafficking, putting the burden of proof on the state.
Drug Use and Coercion During Arrests
One of the critical aspects of the trial has been the testimony of the accused about their behavior on the day Joshyn disappeared.
All three defendants admitted to consuming copious amounts of drugs on that day.
However, Apollus and Fonrain claimed that after their arrest on March 4 of the previous year, they were tortured by the police.
According to their accounts, the police removed their handcuffs and ordered them to remove their sweaters.
They were then handcuffed again and suspended in mid-air.
A plastic bag was placed over their heads, and they were hit repeatedly on their heads, legs, feet, and hands.
The pain was so severe that both men claimed they thought they were going to die.
The issue of coercion and torture during their arrests became a point of contention during the trial.
The defense for Apollus and Fonrain argued that their confessions were obtained under duress and should not be admissible in court.
Despite their claims, the court ruled that the confessions were admissible, allowing the prosecution to use them in building their case.
Inconsistencies in Testimonies and Evidence
Throughout the trial, there have been significant inconsistencies in the testimonies of the accused.
Kelly Smith’s account of the events surrounding Joshyn’s disappearance has raised many questions.
While she initially claimed that Joshyn was with friends, she later admitted to being unaware of her daughter’s whereabouts when she returned home.
Furthermore, the testimonies of Apollus and Fonrain contradicted each other at times, creating confusion and doubt about the truth.
In addition to these inconsistencies, the prosecution has presented circumstantial evidence that supports the claims of trafficking and kidnapping.
The timeline of events, the financial transactions linked to the accused, and the testimony of Lorentia Lombard, a key witness in the case, have all been used to build a strong case against Kelly Smith and her accomplices.
Lombard’s testimony, in particular, has been crucial in linking the accused to the abduction and trafficking of Joshyn.
The Impact on the Family: A Struggle for Justice
While the legal proceedings continue, the emotional toll on Joshyn’s family has been overwhelming.
Her grandmother, Amanda Smith Daniels, has been outspoken about the pain and frustration of not knowing where Joshyn is.
“I’m really not coping,” Amanda said, expressing her anguish over the lack of closure.
The family’s suffering has been compounded by Kelly’s refusal to testify or provide any answers about Joshyn’s whereabouts.
The emotional strain has also affected Joshyn’s siblings.
Amanda revealed that Kelly’s 12-year-old son is struggling to cope with the loss of his sister.
“He’s fighting against the wall, but we are there for support,” Amanda shared.
The family is doing its best to help him through this difficult time, but the emotional scars of losing Joshyn are deep.
The Call for Justice: Where Is Joshyn?
Despite the convictions of Kelly Smith, Jacquwin Apollus, and Stephano Fonrain, the most pressing question remains: where is Joshyn Smith? The family and the community are still waiting for answers.
Amanda has expressed her desire for Kelly to reveal the truth about what happened to Joshyn, stating, “I just want her to tell me where the child is, so I can go and get her.
” The police are continuing their investigation, following up on leads and pursuing all possible avenues to find Joshyn.
As the trial reaches its conclusion, the family is left grappling with the emotional fallout of the case.
While the life sentences handed down to Kelly and her accomplices provide some measure of justice, the pain of not knowing where Joshyn is continues to haunt them.
The search for the missing child will continue, and the hope for closure remains strong.
The Role of the Community in Protecting Children
Joshyn’s case has also highlighted the importance of community involvement in protecting vulnerable children.
The community of Sona Bay came together in an unprecedented show of support to search for Joshyn, and their collective effort played a significant role in the investigation.
However, the case also serves as a reminder of the systemic failures that allowed Joshyn to fall victim to such exploitation.
The need for stronger child protection systems and greater accountability is clear.
A National Conversation on Child Safety and Trafficking
The case of Joshyn Smith has sparked a national conversation about the need to protect children from trafficking and exploitation.
South Africa, with one of the highest rates of child abductions and trafficking in Africa, must take urgent action to address these issues.
The tragedy of Joshyn’s disappearance is a call to reform the country’s child protection systems and ensure that vulnerable children are not left to fall through the cracks.
As the investigation continues and the legal process unfolds, Joshyn’s case serves as a stark reminder of the vulnerabilities children face, even in their own homes.

The fight for justice continues, but the family and the community are still left with one question: where is Joshyn?