Financial Struggles and Downfall: The Untold Stories of PSL Clubs That Couldn’t Survive

The Premier Soccer League (PSL) stands as one of the biggest and most competitive football leagues in Africa, boasting some of the continent’s most iconic clubs such as Orlando Pirates, Kaizer Chiefs, and Mamelodi Sundowns.

These teams have enjoyed considerable success, both domestically and continentally, and have become household names for football fans across the continent.

However, not all clubs that have entered the PSL have managed to thrive. Behind the glitz and glamour of South African football lies a harsh reality: several clubs have faced severe financial struggles that ultimately led to their relegation, dissolution, or complete collapse.

This article sheds light on some of these teams whose journeys serve as cautionary tales about the financial challenges in professional football.

One of the most striking examples is the story of Bloom Fontaine Celtic Bel and Brook.

The owner, Mex Chabalala, once openly pleaded with the PSL for financial assistance to pay his players and prevent the club from collapsing.

The club’s players suffered for months without receiving their salaries, leading to protests where players refused to train.

Chabalala’s financial woes were largely attributed to the collapse of his tender empire, which left him heavily indebted. This financial instability crippled the club’s operations and morale, and despite efforts to salvage the situation, the club could not recover.

Similarly, Morocco Sho’s club was relegated from the PSL during the 2014-2015 season due to overwhelming debts.

The club’s financial difficulties were so severe that it dropped from the PSL to the National First Division (NFD), and then further down to the amateur ABC Mipe League within a single season. Reports indicate that the previous owner, Leon Pins, had to settle debts amounting to approximately 25 million Rand.

This rapid decline highlights how financial mismanagement and lack of sustainable funding can devastate a club’s standing in South African football.

Another case is that of Bidvest Wits Football Club, which was once a respected name in the PSL.

The club management faced accusations of failing to pay players, which resulted in legal battles.

Eventually, businessman Lawrence Mzi purchased the club, but rumors quickly surfaced that players were still not being paid promptly.

The university affiliated with the club withdrew its shareholding after Bidvest Wits failed to find a financial partner to stabilize the club. Ultimately, the club was sold, marking the end of an era for a team that had contributed much to South African football.

Royal AM is yet another club that has been mired in financial turmoil. Owned by Sean Mkeyi (often referred to as Sean Mkey), Royal AM reportedly struggles under a tax debt exceeding 40 million Rand.

The club has also faced a FIFA transfer ban due to a 15 million Rand dispute with former player Samir Nika.

Sean publicly apologized to players after they were not paid their salaries over the festive season, a situation that further damaged the club’s reputation.

As the financial situation worsened, the PSL intervened by suspending Royal AM from both the PSL and the Netbank Cup, underscoring the severity of the crisis.

Jos Sono Football Club, owned and coached by South African football legend Jo Mota, has also experienced a turbulent history marked by financial instability.

The club has oscillated between the Premier Soccer League and the National First Division since the PSL’s inception in 1996, being promoted three times and relegated four times.

Unfortunately, financial difficulties contributed to the club’s relegation to the third tier of South African football at the end of the 2021-2022 season — a first in the club’s history.

This demotion to the GladAfrica Championship and subsequently to the ABC Mipe League reflects the harsh realities many clubs face when finances are mismanaged or insufficient.

These stories collectively paint a sobering picture of the financial challenges that plague many PSL clubs outside the traditional giants.

While clubs like Orlando Pirates and Kaizer Chiefs have robust financial structures and large fan bases to generate revenue, smaller or newer clubs often struggle to maintain financial stability.

The costs associated with running a professional football club — including player wages, stadium maintenance, travel expenses, and administrative costs — are substantial. Without consistent funding, sponsorship, and sound financial management, clubs are vulnerable to collapse.

The consequences of financial instability extend beyond the clubs themselves.

Players suffer when salaries are delayed or unpaid, which affects their morale and performance. Fans lose faith and engagement dwindles, impacting ticket sales and merchandise revenue.

Sponsors are hesitant to invest in clubs with uncertain futures, creating a vicious cycle that is hard to break. Moreover, the league’s overall competitiveness and reputation can be compromised when clubs are unable to field strong teams or maintain professional standards.

To address these issues, the PSL and South African Football Association (SAFA) must adopt stringent financial oversight and support mechanisms.

This could include enforcing stricter licensing criteria that require clubs to demonstrate financial viability before participating in the league.

Additionally, providing financial education and management support to club owners could help prevent mismanagement.

Encouraging partnerships with local businesses and communities may also create more sustainable revenue streams.

In conclusion, the financial struggles of clubs like Bloom Fontaine Celtic Bel and Brook, Morocco Sho’s club, Bidvest Wits, Royal AM, and Jos Sono FC highlight the precarious nature of football club ownership in South Africa.

While the PSL continues to grow in stature and popularity, it is imperative to recognize and address the financial vulnerabilities that threaten the survival of many clubs.

Only through concerted efforts can South African football ensure a stable and competitive future for all its teams.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.